Weekly ratings
| Week | Album | Artist | Thumbs up | Thumbs down | Submitted by | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Week 1 | Rumours | Fleetwood Mac | 9 | 0 | Dylan |  |
| Week 1 | Morning Phase | Beck | 8 | 1 | Alex | |
| Week 2 | Robbie Robertson | Robbie Robertson | 1 | 8 | Andrea |  |
| Week 2 | Imploding the Mirage | The Killers | 1 | 8 | Claire | |
| Week 3 | Thick as a Brick | Jethro Tull | 3 | 6 | Alex | |
| Week 3 | Blood Sugar Sex Magic | Red Hot Chili Peppers | 3 | 6 | Christine | |
| Week 4 | Sound & Color | Alabama Shakes | 5 | 4 | Stacey | |
| Week 4 | Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness | Smashing Pumpkins | 2 | 7 | Steve | |
| Week 5 | Plans | Death Cab for Cutie | 9 | 0 | Claire | |
| Week 5 | A Night at the Opera | Queen | 4 | 5 | Greg | |
| Week 6 | 2001 | Dr. Dre | 1 | 8 | Steve | |
| Week 6 | Play | Moby | 4 | 5 | Christine | |
| Week 7 | The Reminder | Feist | 5 | 4 | Andrea | |
| Week 7 | Give Up | The Postal Service | 5 | 4 | Ian | |
| Week 8 | Nevermind | Nirvana | 5 | 4 | Greg | |
| Week 8 | Nothing Like the Sun | Sting | 3 | 6 | Alex | |
| Week 9 | Sad Hunk | Bahamas | 9 | 0 | Dylan | |
| Week 9 | Come On In | R.L. Burnside | 6 | 3 | Stacey | |
| Week 10 | Lonerism | Tame Impala | ||||
| Week 10 | Hozier | Hozier | ||||